Showing posts with label debating. Show all posts
Showing posts with label debating. Show all posts

Saturday, 3 May 2014

What do you need to bring to a debating competition?

This is the first part of a planned series of basics for new debaters. Feedback is as always appreciated. 

Pens and paper 
You're going to need something to write on and with. While you can always borrow pens and paper from people this gets tiresome quickly.

I've started buying multipacks of generic multicoloured biros because I always lose them (and people 'borrow' them). A useful trick is to write in different colours for different things (e.g. black for your stuff, red for rebuttal or comments). Highlighters can also help. I like using thick marker pens to write titles so they are obvious when glancing at notes (my speaking notes tend to consist of THE TITLE OF THE POINT at the top, and indecipherable squiggles for the rest of the page).

Always use A4 if you can, flipping between  little notepad sheets is distracting for you and the judges. I quite like having a clipboard, especially when you get those annoying side tables on desks.

Time keeping
Its useful to time yourself while speaking (so you don’t suddenly realise you’re still on your first point with one minute left). Many people these days use mobile phones, with either the native stopwatch app or the super shiny Debate Keeper app, which helpfully flashes and/or goes 'bing' at the appropriate times.  Others distrust this modern witchcraft and use traditional stopwatches, which have the benefit of not running out of power or receiving calls from your cousin at inconvenient times.

Crash
In the nicest way possible, the standard of crash can be pretty minimal. Sleeping on a floor with half a dozen other snoring slightly smelly people is not unheard of, so a sleeping bag is a minimal requirement, a sleep mask and/or earplugs might be helpful if you, like me, you have trouble sleeping at the best of times.

Bring whatever you need to feel human in the morning. Minimally spare underwear and deodorant, for the benefit of others if not yourself. Basic makeup if you use it. You can bring a towel, in case you're able to get a shower, and it helps if you're washing yourself in a sink as well (also you always need to know where your towel is). The microfibre ones are particularly good.

Always pack on the side of caution if you can, trains get delayed, you might stay out later than you planned, so spare medication, makeup, clothes can be helpful. Even if you don't plan on crashing its good to have the option.

Food
While tournaments are getting better at feeding people, man cannot live on pizza alone. I swear by the supermarket sandwiches and meal deals personally. And a continuous supply of diet coke (or other caffeinated beverages) keeps me functional.

Knowledge/Case files.
I used to say that knowing things was cheating. Then I realised people who knew stuff were beating me so I amended my view slightly. Facts on their own aren't going to win you debates, but skillful deployment can make a difference. You're not going to be able to learn everything there is to know the night before a tournament, but quickly checking the current status of the various civil wars is probably useful (I wish that comment was sarcastic, but that's the world we live in now). If you know there are particular gaps in your knowledge do your best to correct them, but this will vary between people. Read the top paragraph of the relevant wikipedia pages at least, too many times have I seen things go spectacularly wrong because someone didn't know the difference between NATO and the UN. (I've also written an article on the subject.)

More experienced people often put together a case file (a bunch of printed sheets in a folder with relevant information). The ideal use of this is to be able to quickly look up useful facts in prep time ("Is Iran Sunni or Shia again?"). But this is by no means compulsory, and over focus on it may distract from more important things like actually explaining your points and winning the debate.

Saturday, 22 March 2014

Debating Resources Post Version 2 - Bigger, better and shinier



A book of wordsThis is a creatively named update on my previous Debating Resources Post. Which was itself an update of a stickied post on the Communist Case File Facebook Group, which crowdsources useful information for debaters. I am indebted to everyone who contributed. If you have any additions feel free to post them on the group, in the comments below, or email me at Johnwbh@Googlemail.com.



Debating Guides

The Practical Guide to Debating by Neill Harvey-Smith

Winning Debates - A Guide to Debating in the Style of the World Universities Debating Championships

The Birmingham Competitive debating guide, Kindly donated by James Bowker.


World Universities Debating Championship, Speaker Scale - Used at most BP style debating competitions as well.


General Debating resources

My crowdsourced glossary of debating terminology and jargon.

Googledoc of debating videos 

Shengwu Li’s Blog Lots of excellent advice on improving as a debater and meta-debate discussions.

The Monash Debating Review: (Academic articles on debating.)





Debatekeeper Android App - An excellent application that times debates and beeps at the appropriate times to indicate the beginning and end of protected time.

Useful Background Information Sources

Rob Marr's reading list for World Schools competitors, [Included with his kind permission.]

The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy has good introductory articles on pretty much everything
Personally I prefer The Routledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy, which is slightly more concise, but you’ll need to be on a university network.

The “Very Short Introductions” series is, as you might expect, a good introduction to many topics.

Best textbooks on every subject list on LessWrong.com.



Monash Debaters Association, Matter Guides

The Economist - Generally considered a good resource for concise analysis of political stories. At least one copy can be found at every debating competition.


Debating Blogs and other general community stuff



Miscellaneous interesting articles and websites

Some background on Sharia law: Tl;Dr: If you talk about Sharia as if it’s a universal codified legal system I will hit you with a stick.

The Non-Libertarian FAQ (aka Why I Hate Your Freedom) - A good overview of arguments against libertarianism. Also applies to any general state intervention bad/good debate.

There are times when slippery slopes aren’t an awful argument

The Philosophers Beard

Slate Star Codex - Miscellaneous philosophical writing

LessWrong - Articles on human rationality

A cartoon guide to criminal law - (US based)