Showing posts with label long. Show all posts
Showing posts with label long. Show all posts

Saturday, 29 November 2014

Debating Glossary

Picture unrelated but adorable.
This is a list of terms commonly used in competitive debating based on my crowd-sourced Debating Glossary google doc, but edited to be more concise and less libelous. I am grateful to (almost) all of the contributors.

I suggest using CTRL+F to find particular terms as the list is fairly long.

Please comment below with any additions, requests for clarification, etc.





Term Definition
Ad hominem Arguments that attack the character of a person, not their arguments. Considered very bad form in competitive debating. 
Adjudication team A team of senior judges who set the motions for a competition and decide who judges which debate. (Also called 'CA Team' or "Adjudication Team")
Analysis Explaining why a thing you say is true. See previous post for more details.
Analysis motion/debate A motion/debate about proving a statement is true/false e.g. “This house believes violence is never the answer” is about the truth of that statement, not proposing that a particular action (e.g. “going to war”) is good.
Announce Room The room, generally a large lecture theatre, in which the tab rolls and the CA team and Convening team announce things to the competition.
Assertion When you make a statement but provide no analysis as to why it is true.

Thursday, 9 October 2014

The morality of Debating - In Defense of Sophistry

Many people, both inside and outside the debating community feel a sort of moral unease about debating. People have remarked this when I tell them I debate, and I know debaters who are worried it has made them worse people.

This obviously doesn't come from a utilitarian judgement of the consequences of debating, but a gut feeling that there is something wrong or dishonest about arguing for things that you don't believe in and trying to make yourself as good at that as possible.

This feeling isn't confined to debating. Society feels uncomfortable about lawyers, for their willingness to manipulate facts and defend the guilty, and sales jobs are generally considered slightly sleazy.

Plato offers a POI
And this discomfort isn’t restricted to our current time and culture, it stretches back to the origins of the western intellectual tradition in ancient Greece. Plato’s dialogues[1] tell the story of our hero Socrates, the bringer of truth and logical thinking, father of Philosophy, and his greatest enemies the Sophists.

The Sophists would teach young Athenian gentlemen the dark arts of argument and rhetoric, with the intention of letting them do better in Politics and society at large (in Athens all important decisions were made by popular assembly of the citizens, so being able to speak well literally gave you the power to kill your enemies). And worst of all, for Socrates, the Sophists charged for their teaching.[2]

Socrates decried sophism as the art of making the lesser argument seem the stronger,[3] by deliberately using fallacious reasoning and rhetorical trickery, and believed it to be the enemy of truth (and therefore morality and all other nice things). To Socrates a true Philosopher (a literal lover of wisdom) should use rational argument as a method for seeking the truth of things.

In a weird way I’ve ended up being the modern equivalent of a Sophist. I teach young people how to argue for a living, seeking to make them more persuasive with no regard to truth. I even sell it to them on the basis it will allow them to bluff their way through interviews and meetings. Competitive debating makes people better and better at manipulating the truth to whatever end they are assigned. We train people to never compromise on a position, to treat an argument as about winning and losing, not the pursuit of truth.

So am I a bad person? Is everyone who engages in debating?